Apr 3, 2026
Local News Crisis Is a Design Problem, Not a Funding One
A foundation funds a reporter, the beat lights up, the grant ends, the beat goes dark, the foundation publishes an impact report. Local news was never a funding problem. It was a design problem.
Here's how it usually goes. A foundation announces a multimillion-dollar commitment to local news. A newsroom gets the grant, hires a reporter and starts covering a beat that had gone dark. For two years the coverage is good. Then the grant cycle ends. The reporter leaves. The beat goes dark again. The foundation publishes an impact report.
Penelope ran the same operation in the Odyssey. She wove a burial shroud by day and unpicked it every night, so the work could never be finished. She, at least, was doing it on purpose.
Meanwhile, the newspapers keep closing, more than two a week. Since 2005 the country has lost close to 3,500 of them. Over those same years the Knight Foundation alone has put more than $600 million into journalism and local news, and since 2019 the American Journalism Project has raised more than $250 million. That isn't a coincidence. It's a sign the diagnosis was wrong.
The institutions leading the effort diagnosed a money problem and prescribed money: grants, fellowships, philanthropy, paywalls. The instinct was right. Local journalism is worth fighting for. But the prescription assumed the right revenue source would make the old model work again, and it won't. The model was built for an economy that no longer exists, and no subsidy changes that math.
The best of these efforts deserve precision, so here it is. The American Journalism Project mostly invests in nonprofit newsrooms built for this era, like THE CITY in New York and VTDigger in Vermont. That work matters. But even the most forward-looking philanthropy shares a structural limit: it builds newsrooms one at a time, each with its own fundraising, its own technology and its own overhead. It scales by addition. Every new city needs a new organization, a new board and a new campaign.
That's not how you rebuild coverage in a country with 212 counties that have no local news outlet at all.
What it actually costs
The question I started with wasn't how to save what we have. It was what it actually costs to cover a city if you build the infrastructure from scratch.
The answer: most of the cost was never the journalism. It was everything around it.
I run four publications in two states, The Charlotte Mercury, The Farmington Mercury, Strolling Ballantyne and Strolling Firethorne, on one platform I built called Mercury Local. No building. No press. No sales team. No licensing fee for the publishing software. No middle management. The list of things I don't pay for is the business model. Adding a fifth publication doesn't take a new organization, a new board or a fundraising campaign. It takes a configuration change.
That scales by multiplication, not addition. It's a design difference, not a funding difference.
One reporter at a time
Report for America has placed 759 reporters in 429 newsrooms since 2018. That's serious, valuable work, and I don't dismiss it. But set it against the size of the problem: close to 3,500 papers gone, 212 counties with nothing, about 50 million Americans with limited access to local news or none. The gap won't close one reporter at a time. It closes when someone builds infrastructure that keeps the coverage going without a grant cycle underneath it.
The people behind these efforts are right that local journalism matters. A public body spending hundreds of millions of dollars shouldn't do it unwatched. I share that conviction entirely.
But the instinct to preserve what existed isn't the instinct to build what works. One is nostalgia with a checkbook. The other is a business.
Penelope, at least, knew she was stalling.
Related coverage